A role, not a title
The two words are often confused. Réviseur d'entreprises is a protected professional title, reserved for members of the Institute of Registered Auditors. Commissaire is a role: the one a registered auditor performs when an entity's general meeting entrusts them with the statutory audit of its accounts. Every commissaire is a registered auditor, but a registered auditor is a commissaire only in the entities that appointed them.
Who must appoint one
Appointing a commissaire is mandatory for companies that are not small under the Code of Companies and Associations, meaning those exceeding more than one size criterion for two consecutive financial years. It is also mandatory for large non-profits and foundations under their own criteria, and for some entities subject to special rules, such as public interest entities.
Companies that belong to a group must assess their size on a consolidated basis. A small subsidiary of a large group may therefore have to appoint a commissaire even though its own figures are below the thresholds. Finally, any company may appoint one voluntarily.
The mandate from start to finish
- Appointment: the general meeting appoints the commissaire, usually on the board's proposal. The mandate covers three consecutive financial years and is renewable.
- Fees are set at the start of the mandate. They cover the audit work and cannot be changed along the way without the meeting's approval.
- Audit work runs through the year: understanding the entity, risk assessment, testing internal controls, then auditing the accounts at year end.
- The report goes to the general meeting that approves the accounts, then is filed with them at the Central Balance Sheet Office.
- The mandate ends at its term, unless the auditor is dismissed for just cause or resigns for serious reasons, both situations governed by law.
What the report says
The commissaire's report contains an opinion on the annual accounts. It may be unqualified, qualified or adverse, or take the form of a disclaimer when the auditor could not obtain sufficient evidence. The report also covers other points, such as compliance with certain provisions of the Code and the articles of association, or uncertainty about going concern.
For readers of the published accounts, whether bankers, suppliers or potential buyers, an unqualified report is a sign of confidence. A qualification or a going-concern note, on the other hand, is a signal to look into further.
A growing SME
An industrial SA/NV exceeds two size criteria for the second year in a row: its turnover and headcount are above the thresholds. It is no longer small, and its general meeting must appoint a commissaire. The board consults several audit firms, compares their proposals and puts a candidate to the meeting, which appoints them for three financial years. In the first year, the auditor spends a large share of the work getting to know the company and its procedures, which often makes the first year more expensive.
Auditing is not advising
The commissaire is not management's adviser. Independence prevents them from keeping the books they audit or taking management decisions. They can point out internal control weaknesses in a letter to management, but fixing them is up to the company and its accountant.
The criteria and mandatory cases are set by law and may change. Check your situation with a professional.